I've been thinking about Kay Ryan more these last several days.
A few nights ago, I spent hours scouring writers' blogs. By the end of the evening, I couldn't help but wonder what she would say about our blogging community. In some writing/blogging circles, the idea of building followers is imperative. The idea of creating blogging gimmicks to attract readers is mandatory. The skill of commenting personally yet wittily on each blog you follow is an absolute necessity.
How would Kay handle herself in this world? The answer clearly abides in her choice to stay far removed from it. She does not tweet or blog; she loathes the idea of modern 'mentors' and 'workshopping.' She has never taken or taught a creative writing class. She lives quietly, teaches remedial English, hikes in the desert. No tenure and guest speaking at great universities. No gimmicks. No ambitions beyond living truthfully to herself and to her art.
It's interesting that her privacy may have hampered her success. One article suggests that Ryan's work may have taken decades to attract wide readership in part by her lack of literary connections. But is that such a bad thing? She has said, "I think the people who become the most interesting writers are always going to come from, in some sense, desperate circumstances. There is a great deal of very private testing that has to happen in a writer. It has to be faced. I'm not sure it is good idea to hold hands with others too much."
Holding hands. That's what we're doing as we network on the internet and attend luncheons and retreats. In a way, attending these events is, to me, delightful. And in a way it is, for me, imperative. I don't know that I would have carved out the time necessary to write a novel if Laini hadn't gathered us up and cheered us on. I wouldn't have continued if Jennie and Jay and jldy didn't keep holding my hands through April.
But as I consider Kay Ryan tonight, I wonder what it would take to become a "most interesting writer."Stop blogging? Stop reading blogs? No; I like you guys too much. :) I will stay devoted to a small circle of lovelies whom I enjoy and find inspiring. But I won't believe it when I hear folks say a new writer has to blog, has to have hundreds of followers. We don't have to. We can succeed without them. I think what our poet laureate can teach me is to rely on the wind and the desert, the cup in my hand and the dog howling out back . . . rely on the world to shape my writing, not the computer. And rely on myself to succeed--but, oh, how daunting that sounds.
I will try to blend my delight for connection and need for support with the reality of a writer's inevitable private testing. I'm certain I will not grow roots as deep as Ryan's, but I'll trust I'll blossom sweetly, all the same. :)
Outside Art
Most of it's too dreary
or too cherry red.
If it's a chair, it's
covered with things
the savior said
or should have said--
dense admonishments
in nail polish
too small to be read.
If it's a picture,
the frame is either
burnt matches glued together
or a regular frame painted over
to extend the picture. There never
seems to be a surface equal
to the needs of these people.
Their purpose wraps
around the backs of things
and under arms;
they gouge and hatch
and glue on charms
till likable materials--
apple crates and canning funnels--
lose their rural ease. We are not
pleased the way we thought
we would be pleased.
Let's Have an ALA After-Party!
9 years ago
I think for writers like Kay, that type of life works. I find it appealing in ways myself. However, I could never be without my groups, my friends. I love sharing my writing, even if it's just in small groups. I may never be published, but at least I get to watch the people around me enjoy my writing. I have a group of teens who are my first readers. They are incredibly honest and their critique makes my writing better, my story and my characters stronger. It's fun to share new developments with them. It's flattering when they email me to push me for the next chapter(s) because they really want to know what is happening to my characters. I don't know what I'd do without them.
ReplyDeleteI don't tweet, but I do enjoy my blog. I enjoy other peoples blogs. The tricks I have learned, the writing prompts I have received, the challenges that move me forward with a W.I.P. are beyond measure, in my opinion. I love blogging about the process, my struggles and I'm very grateful to the people who have offered tips when I am stuck. I like the camaraderie that we have found online here. I much prefer friendship and discovery together. Kay Ryan's life is perfect for Kay Ryan but Jennie Bailey prefers our way!
You know, Jen, I've read that the authors for Beautiful Creatures shared their stories with the teens in their lives, too (I think they talk about it in their interview on Amazon). Yeah--receiving that honest eagerness to find out what happens next must be exhilerating. And it's reminiscent, isn't it, of the old serial stories? Publishing one chapter a week (or a month) and leaving the public on the edge of its seat? Surely that pumps the writer with adrenaline. And I imagine that the readers' responses influenced the writer's plot choices.
ReplyDeleteHmm. Very interesting!
Stephen King writes about the idea of keeping the door 'closed' when you're first drafting and then having and 'open' door when you're seeking feedback. I think we've been doing that on these blogs. We've shared very little about our stories, really. What we've shared far more are our journeys--the curiosities, the lessons, the determination to succeed.
I'm speaking in total ignorance, but I want to imagine that even Kay Ryan had (and has) that. I would imagine that she had a loved one or two or three that encouraged her even if she didn't 'network' with the writing community at large. So perhaps she did have some hands to hold? Yes? Maybe? And perhaps, as you and I both adamantly agree, hand holding carries a new writer through!
I enjoyed yr take on Our Kay Ryan, and how her POV might sidestep our "Blogsphere"
ReplyDeleteI keep thinking about just 20 years ago, a writer sends the best of his/her work to small presses or contests maybe, or pays (money well spent) for a "vanity" publication and that this was the ONLY way for someone to get out their art for a small select readership.
Now, we enter a posting and the world can (and does) look in, leave a comment if they like, offer a show of support maybe, but mostly
Thank You for sharing..what you need to.
Is the concluding poem Kays? or yours? G.R.
Hello G.R. and welcome! Thank you for visiting and commenting. Publishing has changed dramatically, hasn't it? In many ways, it seems to be in a new writer's favor, this constant access to readership, advice, support/critique groups, etc. What I wonder about though, is if the quality of new books has at all lessened as writers are more quickly 'discovered' and published. I'd be so interested to find out how many 'promising debut' authors didn't have the chops to produce more quality work.
ReplyDeleteThat will be our challenge, won't it? Along with finishing our books, finding agents and publishers, and navigating the publishing world. We need to prove to ourselves we are so much more than one hit wonders; that we have more than one story to tell.